The biggest cash buyer red flags are a buyer who won’t show verifiable proof of funds, a contract that lets them assign the deal to someone else or cancel at will, a tiny earnest money deposit, pressure to sign fast, and any request for money before closing. A real cash buyer can pass every one of these checks in a day. If a buyer fails even one, slow down before you sign anything.
This guide is for Metro Detroit homeowners who need to sell quickly and want to avoid repairs and traditional fees. Speed is the reason cash offers appeal to you. It is also the reason bad actors target you.
TL;DR
- Ask for a proof-of-funds letter in the buyer’s own name, then verify it by calling the bank at a number you find yourself.
- Read the contract for assignment language, a buyer-only right to cancel, and an open-ended inspection period.
- Earnest money should be meaningful and held by a title company or attorney, never paid to the buyer.
- Never pay a fee, appraisal charge or “processing” cost before closing, and verify any wire instructions by phone.
- A high first offer followed by a price cut is a pattern, not bad luck.
Table of Contents
- Why a cash offer deserves a closer look
- Red flags in proof of funds
- Red flags in the contract
- Red flags in price and pace
- Red flags about money before closing
- Quick scorecard
- What to do when you spot a red flag
- Compare vetted local buyers before you choose
- FAQ
- Sources
Why a cash offer deserves a closer look
A cash offer is not a red flag by itself. NerdWallet notes that an all-cash offer can be fast and convenient, but that cash buyers often offer less than financed buyers, in effect discounting the price for convenience. So the question is never just “is it cash?” It is whether the buyer can actually close, whether the contract protects you, and whether the price is worth the speed.
That is also why you should compare your options. Our ranked list of cash home buyers in Metro Detroit exists so you can see several local providers side by side before one calls you with a “final” offer.
Red flags in proof of funds
Proof of funds (POF) is a document showing the buyer has the money. It is the first thing to ask for and the first place weak buyers stumble. Our guide on proof of funds for cash home buyers goes deeper. Here are the warning signs.
1. The buyer refuses or stalls
A buyer who says they will “send it later” or only after you sign has told you what you need to know. Documentation is cheap for a buyer who has the funds.
2. The document is old or doesn’t match the offer
NerdWallet says proof of funds should generally be dated within the past 30 to 90 days and show readily accessible funds. It also cautions that proof can be fake. Check three things on the page: the buyer’s name matches the name on the purchase agreement, the balance covers the full offer, and the date is recent.
3. You haven’t verified the source
A convincing letter is not verification. Look up the bank’s main number yourself, not the one printed on the letter, and confirm the document is real. If the buyer is a company, you can also look up the business in your state’s corporate registry. In Michigan that is a quick search of the state’s business entity records.
4. The “funds” aren’t actually cash
A letter from a hard-money lender means the buyer is financing the purchase, which makes it a financed deal wearing a cash label. Equity in another property, retirement account balances and screenshots of crypto wallets are also not cash in hand. If the buyer’s money is borrowed or tied up, the closing risk is yours.
Red flags in the contract
The contract matters more than the phone call. Read every page, and if a term doesn’t match what was promised verbally, don’t sign until it does.
5. “And/or assigns” or an assignment clause
An assignment clause lets the buyer pass your contract to someone else. Wholesalers do this: they put a house under contract and market it to other investors. AARP warns that if the contract doesn’t sell quickly, closing may not happen at all. ProPublica’s reporting found language such as an option to market the property and assign the agreement before closing, which signals that a higher bidder may exist.
Assignment is not illegal when disclosed. The red flag is a buyer who never mentions it and calls themselves “the buyer” while planning to hand the deal off. A simple question settles it: whose name will be on the deed at closing?
6. The buyer can cancel, but you can’t
ProPublica found that in many wholesale contracts the buyer reserves the sole right to cancel. Combine that with a vague inspection period and you have given someone a free option on your house while it sits off the market.
7. A tiny earnest money deposit
Earnest money is the deposit that shows the buyer is serious and compensates you if they walk away. ProPublica reviewed contracts with deposits as low as $100 on a $157,000 deal, and notes a broad rule of thumb of 1% of the purchase price. The deposit should go to a title company or closing attorney, not to the buyer. Read our guides on earnest money in Michigan and protecting earnest money in Detroit for typical amounts and refund rules. The American Bar Association also says the agreement should state when earnest money is returned and set a firm possession date.
8. No expiration date or a very long due-diligence period
AARP reports that some “we buy your home” contracts have no expiration date and can last for years, making it impossible to sell to someone else. Inspection and due-diligence periods of weeks or months do the same thing more quietly. Ask for a short, clearly defined period and a firm closing date. Our piece on home offer contingencies explains which conditions are normal.
9. Paperwork that isn’t what you were told
AARP also describes scammers in North Carolina who told homeowners they were signing a receipt for a cash advance when they were signing a purchase agreement or a deed. If anyone describes a document as a formality, read it as if it were the deed. For a plain-language look at paperwork that can trip sellers up, this overview of real estate transaction hurdles is a useful companion, and a real estate attorney should review any contract before you sign.
10. “Clear title” language that shrinks your check
Many cash contracts require clear title, meaning no liens or debts attached to the property. ProPublica explains that mortgage liens, overdue water bills and back taxes can be subtracted from your final price: a $100,000 offer minus $25,000 in bills pays you $75,000. A title report costs $50 to $250 according to the same reporting, and it is worth running before you accept any number. If you owe the IRS, the steps in this guide to clearing an IRS lien before a sale show why timing matters. Our guide to selling a house with liens and our breakdown of Michigan seller closing costs will help you estimate what you would actually net.

Red flags in price and pace
11. An offer far above every other offer, then a price cut
This is a known tactic. A buyer bids above what the house is worth to win the contract, which takes your home off the market. During the inspection period, they find “problems” or shop the contract to other investors, then call to lower the price and demand a fast close. By then you may have turned away other buyers and be short on time.
Protect yourself with three questions before you sign: how long the inspection period lasts, what specifically lets the buyer change the price, and how much earnest money you keep if they walk. An outlier offer paired with vague answers is a signal to compare it with others.
You also need a baseline. Check your home’s value with a local agent, your county assessor’s records, or an online estimate. AARP notes that scammers count on homeowners not knowing what their home is worth. Be aware that assessed value and market value are different numbers, so use the assessor’s figure as one data point, not the answer.

12. Pressure to sign now
Deadlines of a few hours, “best and final” claims on the first call and annoyance when you want an attorney to look at the contract are all pressure tactics. ProPublica quotes Michael Froehlich of Community Legal Services in Philadelphia: “Don’t sign anything right away.” A buyer with real funds doesn’t lose the deal because you took a day.
AARP also advises not replying to pestering calls, emails or texts, even to complain, because a reply tells the sender your number is live. Block the number, add yours to the FTC Do Not Call list, and forward spam texts to 7726.
Red flags about money before closing
A legitimate buyer pays you at closing. It is not the other way around.
- Any upfront fee. Appraisal, inspection, processing or “due diligence” fees paid by the seller before closing are a reason to walk away.
- Cash “on the side.” The California Department of Real Estate’s fraud-prevention guide lists paying cash, paying outside of escrow, paying upfront fees, wiring money from emailed instructions and sending financial information by email as red flags. It is a California document, but these warning signs apply anywhere.
- Unlicensed people handling the deal. Check any agent’s license with your state regulator. In Michigan, that is the state licensing department.
- Last-minute wire changes. CertifID’s 2024 alert describes fake wiring instructions that copy a title agent’s format and logos, sent as closing nears with pressure not to tell anyone. The funds are typically withdrawn before the fraud is found. A Minnesota closing-fraud article reports median losses in CertifID’s 2025 caseload of $343,497 for seller net proceeds fraud and $389,125 for mortgage payoff fraud. Its advice is to verify proceeds instructions in person at the closing table and treat any later change as fraudulent until proven otherwise.
Quick scorecard
| Warning sign | What a safe version looks like |
|---|---|
| No proof of funds | Dated letter or statement in the buyer’s name, bank verified by you |
| Hard-money or borrowed funds | Liquid cash at or above the full price |
| Assignment clause not explained | Buyer states in writing that they will close in their own name |
| Buyer-only cancellation right | Clear, mutual terms and a short inspection window |
| $100-style deposit | Meaningful earnest money held by a title company or attorney |
| No end date on the contract | Firm closing date in writing |
| Offer far above all others | Price within the range of local comparables |
| Deadline of hours | Time to read and get legal review |
| Fees before closing | You pay nothing until you are paid |
What to do when you spot a red flag
- Stop and don’t sign. Nothing is lost by pausing a day.
- Ask the question in writing. A legitimate buyer answers email questions plainly.
- Get a second opinion on the contract. A real estate attorney can read an assignment clause or title requirement in minutes. AARP notes that unwinding a signed purchase agreement can be difficult and expensive.
- Run the quick checks. Our 5 quick checks to verify a cash home buyer takes you through the basics, and our guide to “we buy houses” scams covers the scripts to watch for.
- Report scams. AARP lists your state attorney general, the real estate commission, and the FBI’s IC3 for online scams.
Our view: speed shouldn’t cost you the sale
We hear the same story from distressed sellers: a foreclosure date, an inherited house, a job move. When time is short, the first offer feels like the only offer. That is exactly when the red flags above are hardest to see.
That is why we publish independently researched rankings rather than paid listings. Providers cannot pay for placement on CompareSpot, and our lists are built from research and customer sentiment in Wayne, Oakland and Macomb counties, then updated quarterly with a transparent methodology.
Our advice is simple: line up two or three vetted local buyers, get each offer in writing with proof of funds, and compare the price, the earnest money and the timeline side by side. Competition is the best protection a seller has.
Bryan
Compare vetted local buyers before you choose
If you are selling in Metro Detroit, start with our 10 best cash home buyers in Metro Detroit, ranked on independent research and customer sentiment, with no paid placement. We also have city pages for Royal Oak, Madison Heights and Sterling Heights. If you would rather list traditionally and compare, see our real estate agents in Metro Detroit.

Buyers on the other side of the table can also compare options on our Metro Detroit mortgage lenders ranking.
FAQ
How do you know if a cash buyer is legit?
Ask for proof of funds in the buyer’s name, dated recently, and verify it by calling the bank at a number you found yourself. Confirm who will be on the deed at closing, and make sure earnest money goes to a title company or attorney. A legitimate buyer will answer all of this without pressure.
Is buying a house in cash a red flag?
No. Paying cash is normal and can speed up a closing. The warning signs are in the details: missing proof of funds, assignment clauses, tiny deposits, or a price that drops after you sign.
Why would a seller want a cash buyer?
Cash offers can close faster and skip the loan approval step, which helps sellers facing a deadline, an inherited property or a relocation. NerdWallet notes the trade-off is that cash offers are often lower than financed ones, so compare before you accept.
Should I pay anything before closing?
No. Appraisal, inspection, processing and due-diligence fees paid by the seller before closing are red flags. You should be paid at closing, and any wire instructions should be confirmed by phone with your title company.
Sources
- Should I Accept a Cash Offer for My House? (NerdWallet)
- Want to Sell Your Home for Cash? Read This First (ProPublica)
- Beware of ‘Let Us Buy Your Home’ Ads (AARP)
- Buying or Selling a Home (American Bar Association)
- Preventing Real Estate Fraud (California Department of Real Estate)
- Industry Alert: Buyer Cash to Close Fraud Increasing (CertifID)
- Wire Fraud at a Minnesota Closing
- Clearing an IRS lien before a sale
- Navigating real estate transaction hurdles
- Assessed value vs market value

